Intergovernmental Relations in Federal Systems : Ubiquitous, Idiosyncratic, Opaque and Essential

Poirier, Johanne

Abstract

Regardless of institutional design, all federal systems imply substantial degrees of interaction between federal partners. “Intergovernmental relations” (IGR) refer to the many modalities through which this interaction takes place. IGR take many shapes and forms. They fluctuate with time and according to policy areas. In this sense, they are idiosyncratic. They are, however, the essential “oil in the machinery” of every federal system, and as such may be rather ubiquitous. Following a short incursion in the terminological challenges relating to intergovernmental relations (and its companion: “comparative federalism”), this article explores the actors in the IGR game as well as the rich catalogue of legislative – and mostly executive-techniques on which these actors rely to structure their relations. IGR waltz between institutionalization and informality, often in an opaque fashion which tends to reinforce the executive branch of each federal partner.

This brief overview of IGR from a comparative perspective suggests that federations grounded in the “continental civil law tradition” are more likely to structure IGR through legal mechanisms and norms than their more pragmatic “common law” counterparts. Though this is a significant simplification, the latter tend to consider IGR primarily (if not exclusively) through a political lens. Yet – somewhat paradoxically – regardless of informality and legal status, IGR play similar functions in various federal systems. Coordination functions, of course. But also para-constitutional engineering ones, through which federal actors (generally the various executives) implicitly alter the official federal architecture.


Poirier, J. (2018). “Intergovernmental Relations in Federal Systems : Ubiquitous, Idiosyncratic, Opaque and Essential”, Fifthy Shades of Federalism                                                                                                                            http://50shadesoffederalism.com/theory/intergovernmental-relations-in-federal-systems-ubiquitous-idiosyncratic-opaque-and-essential/

 

Pour commander le livre

Observatoire des Diasporas

Observatoire des Diasporas

Bibliothèque virtuelle

Appels à communication

Bourses et concours

Notre infolettre

Suivez-nous:

CRIDAQ filigrane